Since I am a filmmaker, and I view films from several different aspects I can tell you a real perspective. Both films are definitely the s***, and I can understand people having a hard time choosing. But three things stick out that make one of the films the better of the two. cinematography(camera angles/visual look), story/writing(like someone said earlier suspense, action, drama, comedy this film had it all), and acting. JUICE hands down was the better of the two, if Tupac had played any role in MIIS that would have made it a tie in acting, but JUICE still wins 2 out of the 3 categories.
And since this is THISIS50 and I know this is another argument starter---Juice also had the better soundtrack:)
juice got this s*** by a landslide lol menace was coo,but had its slow parts imo, juice flowed very fluently and had a banging ass soundtrack indeed, imo the last dragon has the best movie soundtrack of all time though. "i ain't trying too tell u s***, ill tell ya mama u aint s***!!!"
yeh menace was straight, towards the end when theyre at the park then later shareefs tlking w his pops they couldve took out cus i fall asleep and wake up on the credits,lol.